Federal Court Affirms Rights of Excluded Métis Communities
Press Release
June 30, 2025
The BC Métis Federation acknowledges a significant Federal Court ruling that reaffirms the rights of Métis communities who have been excluded from federal processes based on arbitrary and inconsistent standards.
In Lac Ste. Anne Métis Community Association v. Canada (Finance), 2025 FC 864, the Court found that the Government of Canada acted unfairly when it excluded the Lac Ste. Anne Métis Community Association (LSAMCA) from participating in national Indigenous economic initiatives. Despite a decade of engagement and consultation, LSAMCA was eventually dismissed on the grounds that it was not “federally recognized”—a requirement the Court determined was inconsistently applied and not grounded in fact.
The Court found that:
- Canada had no factual basis to challenge LSAMCA’s status as a rights-bearing Métis community
- The government’s criteria were not applied consistently. While the applicants were assessed against the eligibility criteria, other groups—including many who would not have met the same test—were not
- The government’s criteria were reverse engineered to exclude certain groups who had been targeted for exclusion
- The requirement for formal “federal recognition” under section 35 was not rationally linked to the stated purpose of ensuring economic benefits only flowed to “legitimate” Indigenous groups
This decision has far-reaching implications for other Métis communities across the country who continue to be sidelined in favour of a single government-recognized organization. It highlights the legal risks of selective recognition policies and reaffirms that Indigenous rights cannot be defined solely by political convenience.
The BC Métis Federation commends LSAMCA for standing up for the rights of its members. Their legal victory represents a broader step forward in the fight for equitable treatment, respect for diverse governance models, and the right of all Métis communities to be heard and included.
ILR4
